Chance Miller, 9to5Mac:

In macOS 27.2, “Device Control and Data Access” is a unified toggle in System Settings, where Apple says that apps with that level of access can “view and send email, edit contacts and photos, monitor your keyboard, track websites, record your screen, control any app on your Mac, and more.”

In macOS 27.3, Apple is splitting “Device Control and Data Access” into two categories:

  • Accessibility: Intended specifically for assistive technologies, with permissions handled through an entitlement process.
  • System and App Protection Override: A new category for apps that need to bypass certain macOS protections to control other apps or perform automated tasks.

For the latter, users will be able to specify which apps an automation tool can access rather than granting it unrestricted control. For instance, you could give an app access to the Mail app, but not Messages.

macOS 27.3 also adds an option for users to require an app to request permission every time it needs access, rather than granting it access indefinitely…

Crucially, Apple isn’t removing the ability to give an app Full Disk Access. If you deem it necessary, you can still give an app Full Disk Access. However, Apple is redesigning the approval process to make the implications of that decision more obvious.

macOS 27.3 will display a more detailed explanation about the protections being bypassed and the types of personal information that could be exposed.

Users can also choose to grant an app access to specific folders instead of their entire Mac. For example, an app that only needs to work with files in a particular folder won’t get unrestricted access to everything else.

It’s worth noting that Device Control and Full Disk Access are two separate branches of control. Device Control lets apps use the accessibility application programming interfaces in macOS; the apps I have given that access to include Claude and ChatGPT for computer use. These agents use macOS by reading the screen’s contents, similar to VoiceOver, and therefore require Device Control, not Full Disk Access. The latter gives an app access to all file directories on a user’s computer, including dot files — directories hidden by the system because they are deemed crucial.

Apple initially said it would lock down Full Disk Access, not Device Control, after reports of rogue agents reading sensitive messages and data on disk. Full Disk Access, aside from the new scare screen, has not changed. macOS now merely dissuades people from giving Full Disk Access permission to apps that almost certainly don’t need it. (Artificial intelligence agents are a good example.) macOS 27.3 also provides an easier way to limit access to just a few folders, which I predicted in October. AI nerds on social media, in their typical propensity to complain about almost everything that doesn’t benefit them, are unhappy with the permission prompt. While I think the design can be refined, I believe such prompts are necessary in an era where the companies that make these agents have little regard for user data protection or privacy. AI agents do not need Full Disk Access.

Accessibility permissions are more nuanced, but I generally don’t think Apple overreached here, either. The option remains to let an app control the entire system; such permissions are required for text snippet expansion, audio controls, etc. This is one of the hallmark power user features of the Mac and shouldn’t be removed — but it should be harder to provide an app with this unprecedented level of access. Apple should provide developers with an API to actively prompt for more limited access. As of macOS 27.3 Beta 2, they can either prompt for full access or must somehow handle the case where access is manually limited to a few apps by a user. AI agents currently take the liberty of handling such granular permissions themselves (e.g., “ChatGPT would like to control Safari”), but users are more likely to trust the system, not the harness, with sandboxing the agent.